In what can only be described as one of the most bizarre—and controversial—proposals in recent memory, Fox News contributor and former pro wrestler Tyrus has pitched a jaw-dropping solution to the nation’s detention issues: an “Alligator Alcatraz.” This off-the-wall idea, which would see detainees housed on a remote island surrounded by the most dangerous reptiles America has to offer, has taken the internet by storm, generating fierce debate and wild reactions from both critics and supporters alike.

The Pitch: Alligator-Guarded Detention?

The proposal came during a fiery panel discussion on Gutfeld! where Tyrus was asked to weigh in on the country’s detention practices, particularly the treatment of those held by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). Without missing a beat, Tyrus suggested creating a new form of detention center: a remote, swamp-guarded island dubbed “Alligator Alcatraz.”

“Let’s put them on an island,” Tyrus said with his signature grin, “surrounded by America’s most patriotic reptiles—alligators. They won’t swim through freedom-hating alligators.” The remark, half-joking but dead serious in tone, prompted awkward laughter from the panel but stunned silence from some of his co-hosts.

The idea, as outlandish as it seemed, immediately exploded online. Critics called the proposal inhumane, dystopian, and deeply dehumanizing, while Tyrus’ supporters championed it as “creative justice.” The juxtaposition of humor and horror in Tyrus’ pitch exposed the stark divide in how Americans approach issues of punishment, immigration, and detention.

The Debate: A Line Between Satire and Seriousness?

The suggestion, though clearly over-the-top, resonated with a segment of Tyrus’ fanbase, who appreciated his unapologetic approach to controversial topics. “Creative justice,” some commented, applauding his willingness to think outside the box—however unconventional the idea may be. “Sometimes you need something as wild as this to shake up the system,” one fan wrote on social media.

But not everyone was laughing.

Civil rights groups quickly condemned the rhetoric, with the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) and others calling it “dehumanizing” and “irresponsible.” One advocate stated, “This isn’t a solution—it’s a spectacle. Using animals as a deterrent for human beings shows a profound lack of empathy and understanding of the moral consequences of incarceration.”

The mix of humor and brutality in Tyrus’ remarks had some questioning whether he was genuinely advocating for such a policy or whether it was simply a theatrical statement designed to provoke discussion and attention. Still, Tyrus doubled down on his idea, further cementing his stance in the face of backlash.

Tyrus Doubles Down: ‘Wetter and with More Teeth’

Despite the outcry, Tyrus didn’t back down. “If it worked for Alcatraz, it can work again,” he said, leaning further into the absurdity of the proposal. “Just wetter, with more teeth.” His boldness and irreverence only served to heighten the controversy. The line between satire and serious policy became increasingly blurred as Tyrus continued to play into the absurdity of his own suggestion, fueling both support and criticism in equal measure.

His comment about “freedom-hating alligators” and the idea of a natural “deterrent” had people scrambling to figure out whether Tyrus was calling for a literal version of the proposal or if he was mocking the overuse of punitive solutions in the debate over immigration and criminal justice reform.

Social Media Erupts: ‘Alligator Alcatraz’ Takes Over

As clips of the segment circulated on social media, hashtags like #AlligatorAlcatraz and #TyrusRevolution began trending. Supporters rallied behind the concept, arguing that traditional detention methods weren’t working and that something radical—if not literally alligators—was needed to address the U.S.’s overcrowded immigration system.

“I can’t believe I’m saying this, but I actually like the idea of Alligator Alcatraz,” one user tweeted. “The system is broken, and we need new ideas, even if they sound wild at first.”

Others, however, were horrified by the proposal, saying it trivialized the real human rights issues at the border. “This is exactly why we need more compassion in our immigration system, not ridiculous spectacle,” one commenter wrote. Another noted, “This is a reflection of how little regard some people have for the dignity of immigrants. Using alligators is cruel and disgusting.”