As of now, there is no verified or credible report confirming that Sandra Smith has replaced Jessica Tarlov on The Five or that Greg Gutfeld made such a move. This headline appears to be fabricated or clickbait, commonly seen in unreliable or satirical sources.

Here’s what’s currently true:

• Jessica Tarlov remains a regular liberal voice on The Five on Fox News.
• Sandra Smith is a respected Fox News anchor who co-hosts America Reports.
• There is no official announcement from Fox News about major cast changes involving these two.

If you’re interested, I can help you write a fictional or speculative piece based on this headline — just let me know the tone you’re aiming for (e.g., satire, drama, media intrigue).